This is an archived edition. For the latest picks see NHL Goalscorer Props Today, updated every game day.
Best NHL Goalscorer Props Today: Anytime Goal Picks for Tuesday, November 17
Every prop on today's slate, ranked live: NHL Player Props Today
The picks
3 picksPicks are opinions, not guarantees. Odds may have moved since publishing.
I went through all 11 games on Tuesday, November 17 to find the best anytime goalscorer props on the board. The picks below are ranked by PropFinder's Goalscorer Matchups score, which blends a skater's own scoring form with how much the opposing defense and goalie give up.
Scores run from 0 to 100, where 50 is league average, so a 90 form score is well above a typical skater. Here are the top three anytime goal props for tonight.
Macklin Celebrini to score a goal (+135, FanDuel)
Macklin Celebrini
Anytime Goalscorer
Opposing goalie: Dustin Wolf (Expected)
Macklin Celebrini has 9 goals in 21 games for San Jose, backed by a 96 form score. He averages 4.19 shots and 0.95 individual high-danger chances per game, and he plays 23:07 a night including 4:45 on the power play. His 9.70 expected goals sit right next to his 9 actual goals, so the production looks sustainable rather than lucky.
Calgary is a 79 matchup score for him. The Flames allow centers 8.33 scoring chances, 4.00 high-danger chances and 7.19 shots per game, and 1.05 goals. Dustin Wolf is the expected starter with a .875 save percentage over 11 games. FanDuel offers +135, better than the +120 median across 7 books. Strong form against a leaky defense makes the plus price worth it.
Tim Stutzle to score a goal (+180, FanDuel)
Tim Stutzle
Anytime Goalscorer
Opposing goalie: Stuart Skinner (Expected)
Tim Stutzle has 11 goals in 21 games for Ottawa and a 93 form score. He shoots less than most scorers at 2.43 per game, but he gets 1.05 individual high-danger chances per game and 21:53 of ice time with 4:02 on the power play. His 11 goals come from 6.10 expected goals, so some finishing luck is baked in, and his 16.2% shooting is hard to repeat.
The matchup is the best of the three, an 81 score. Winnipeg gives up 8.43 scoring chances, 4.29 high-danger chances and 7.33 shots per game to centers, plus 1.38 goals. Stuart Skinner is the expected starter at .880 over 15 games. FanDuel has +180, above the +169 median across 11 books. The soft Jets defense is why he stays on the list despite the finishing regression risk.
Brandon Hagel to score a goal (+200, DraftKings)
Brandon Hagel
Anytime Goalscorer
Opposing goalie: Logan Thompson (Expected)
Brandon Hagel has 13 goals in 20 games for Tampa Bay and a 95 form score. He takes 4.00 shots and generates 2.05 individual high-danger chances per game, the highest rate of the three picks. His 13 goals match 10.70 expected goals closely enough, with a 15.3% shooting rate. He plays 20:32 a night, 3:31 of it on the power play.
Washington is a 76 matchup score. Wingers on the left side get 7.83 scoring chances, 4.11 high-danger chances and 6.89 shots per game against the Capitals, who also allow 1.17 goals. Logan Thompson is expected in goal with a .889 save percentage over 13 games. DraftKings has the best price at +200, well above the +160 median across 11 books. High-danger volume at a plus price is the case here.
Anytime Goal Parlay
Combining the three legs into one anytime goal parlay pays +1874 at the prices above. Odds are subject to change.
Affiliate disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Must be of legal age to wager. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, support is available: call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Odds and lines were accurate at the time of publishing and are subject to change. Must be 21+ and physically located in a jurisdiction where wagering is legal. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Jake Casso
Jake is a Chicago native and lifelong sports enthusiast who brings energy, creativity, and expertise to the PropFinder team. He plays a key role in developing educational livestreams and producing YouTube content that helps sports bettors better understand betting markets, strategies, and data-driven insights.
Related reading
NHL Picks Today: Moneyline and Total Picks for Tuesday, November 17
NHL moneyline and total picks for Tuesday, November 17, including Edmonton Oilers at Florida Panthers and Buffalo Sabres at Philadelphia Flyers, from PropFinder's game projections.
Best NHL Goalscorer Props Today: Anytime Goal Picks for Monday, November 16
Today's top three NHL anytime goal props for Monday, November 16: Clayton Keller, Nick Suzuki, and Kailer Yamamoto.
Best NHL Goalscorer Props Today: Anytime Goal Picks for Sunday, November 15
Today's top three NHL anytime goal props for Sunday, November 15: Steven Stamkos, Macklin Celebrini, and Leon Draisaitl.
Find profitable props faster
PropFinder has all the tools to help you make smarter bets and find real edges with data-driven insights. Weighing your options? Compare Player Prop Tools side by side.