Best NHL Goalscorer Props Today: Anytime Goal Picks for Wednesday, November 4

I went through all 4 games on Wednesday, November 4 to find the best anytime goalscorer props on the NHL board. The three picks below are ranked by PropFinder's Goalscorer Matchups score, which blends a skater's own scoring form with how much the opposing defense and goalie give up.

Scores in this post run from 0 to 100, where 50 is league average, so a 90 form score means a skater is producing well above the typical player. Every number comes from PropFinder's NHL data, and prices are the best available at press time.

Sam Reinhart to score a goal (+155, theScore)

ANYTIME GOALSCORERCHI@FLA· Nov 4, 7:30 PM ET

Sam Reinhart

Anytime Goalscorer

Opposing goalie: Spencer Knight (Expected)

Bet now+155

Sam Reinhart has 8 goals in 15 games for Florida and a 97 form score, which is elite. He averages 3.07 shots and 1.6 individual high-danger chances per game, and his 7.26 expected goals are close to the 8 he has scored, so the production looks earned rather than lucky. He plays about 20 minutes a night, including just over five minutes per game on the power play, which is where much of his scoring threat comes from. His 15.5% shooting percentage is healthy without being out of line.

Chicago gives up 10.13 scoring chances, 4.87 high-danger chances, 7.8 shots and 1.27 goals per game to opposing centers, which earns an 83 matchup score. Spencer Knight is the expected starter in the Chicago net and carries a .894 save percentage over 12 games. Reinhart is +155 at theScore, better than the +143 median across 10 books. A top-tier shooter facing a leaky defense at a plus price is the case here.

Drake Batherson to score a goal (+186, Novig)

ANYTIME GOALSCOREROTT@BUF· Nov 4, 7:30 PM ET

Drake Batherson

Anytime Goalscorer

Opposing goalie: Colten Ellis (Expected)

Bet now+186

Drake Batherson has 9 goals in 16 games for Ottawa, and he has outscored his 4.46 expected goals by a wide margin, so some cooling is possible. Still, his 89 form score reflects real volume: 2.31 shots and 1.06 individual high-danger chances per game, plus about 17.5 minutes of ice time and roughly four minutes a night on the power play. He is shooting 17.7% this season, which is well above typical, so the finishing is the part to watch.

Buffalo allows right wingers 8.71 scoring chances, 3.79 high-danger chances, 8.43 shots and 1.29 goals per game, good for a 90 defense score and an 88 matchup score. Colten Ellis is expected in net with a .880 save percentage, though that is only five games, so the sample is small. Batherson is +186 at Novig versus a +170 median across 9 books. Strong form against a soft defense and a shaky goalie makes the case.

Tage Thompson to score a goal (+133, Novig)

ANYTIME GOALSCOREROTT@BUF· Nov 4, 7:30 PM ET

Tage Thompson

Anytime Goalscorer

Opposing goalie: Samuel Ersson (Expected)

Bet now+133

Tage Thompson has 10 goals in 14 games for Buffalo, the most of the three picks, and a 92 form score. He fires 4.5 shots per game, the highest volume here, with 1.36 individual high-danger chances per game. His 6.51 expected goals trail his 10 actual goals, so he is finishing above expectation. He plays about 19.5 minutes a night, with about three and a half minutes on the power play, and shoots 14.1% on the season.

Ottawa allows centers 8.25 scoring chances, 4.19 high-danger chances, 7.31 shots and 0.94 goals per game, a 79 matchup score that is solid but not extreme. Samuel Ersson is expected in the Senators net with a .866 save percentage over 7 games, a weak mark with a small sample. Thompson is +133 at Novig, just above the +130 median across 8 books. Elite shot volume against a shaky goalie is the reason to back him.

Affiliate disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Must be of legal age to wager. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, support is available: call 1-800-GAMBLER.